Blog
TCA Pulls Permit Application: Backing Away from Rejected Toll Road Alignment?
Written by Marty Benson   
Thursday, 26 February 2009

TCA's withdrawal of its Clean Water Certification Application may suggest abandonment of 241 Extension which threatens San Onofre and Donna O'Neil Land Conservancy.

 
We Must Continue to Make Our Voices Heard
Written by Nancy Mooney   
Tuesday, 23 December 2008
As the repercussions of the Toll Road rejection are felt, we must remember that this does not mean the fight to protect San Onofre is over. 
 
Department of Commerce Rejects TCA Toll Road!
Written by Nancy Mooney   
Monday, 22 December 2008

TOLL ROAD APPEAL DENIED!

***

Bush Administration Rejects Toll Road Agency Request to Override California Decision:

***

U.S. Commerce Department Says Toll Road Not in National

Interest and Alternatives Exist

 
Save San Onofre Retrospective
Written by Nancy Mooney   
Monday, 22 December 2008
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cVJBGITwjg&feature=channel_page
 
OCTA Major Investment in TCA
Written by Nancy Mooney   
Thursday, 04 December 2008
The OCTA is embarking on an extremely flawed 
transportation plan which makes OCTA subservient 
to the TCA and many of its maladies. OCTA is 
shirking its commitment to the people of Orange County.


 
See Coalition case for no override of Coastal Commission decision
Tuesday, 16 September 2008
Coalition "Comment Letters" Submitted to NOAA

Our Coalition submitted two letters to NOAA, making our case that "there is no basis in law or fact for the Secretary of Commerce to override the California Coastal Commission's objection" to building the Foothill South Toll Road.

Letter 1

Letter 2


 
New Hearing Set in Del Mar on September 22nd
Written by Dan Geary   
Tuesday, 26 August 2008

The Dept. of Commerce hearing on the TCA’s request to overturn the Coastal Commission decision has finally been rescheduled for September 22, 10:30 AM to 8:30 PM, at the Del Mar Fairgrounds' O'Brien Hall.

The rules at this hearing are significantly different, and we need your help – and quickly!

First - your attendance at the hearing is critical to show the Dept. of Commerce how strongly the public opposes the Toll Road through San Onofre State Beach.

The hearing before the Coastal Commission in February proved how effective our presence can be.  PLEASE JOIN US ONCE AGAIN IN DEL MAR!

Second – If you wish to speak at the hearing, you need to submit a written request to NOAA at the Dept. of Commerce – which must be sent via US mail or commercial carrier, not fax or email, and must be received at NOAA by Sept. 12.  Only those who submit a written request by the deadline will be granted an opportunity – by the Dept. of Commerce – to speak.  (For additional detail on the rules for this hearing, go to:  http://www.savesanonofre.com/downloads/CommerceHearingFAQs.pdf


Include the information below in your request to speak:


Thomas Street, NOAA Office of General Counsel for Ocean Services
1305 East-West Highway, Room 6111
Silver Spring, MD 20910

Dear Mr. Street,

I wish to speak at the public hearing on September 22 in Del Mar, CA.  I will speak on my own behalf as an individual, not representing an organization.

Thank you,

Name:

Address:


Send your speaking request by mail or overnight delivery to Mr. Street at the address above. Your request must be received by NOAA, in Maryland, no later than close of business on September 12, 2008. 

Feel free to address questions or concerns to:  This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it .

Hope to see you at the hearing on the 22nd!!

 
TCA - is OC's Circus Act
Monday, 07 April 2008

written by Jerry Collamer

TCA complains, us State-Park-Loving citizens
do protest too much TCA's skewed misinformation
as TCA finagles to pave thru world renowned San Onofre
State Beach Park for a private toll-road to nowhere
few would ever afford at $15 one-way. As gas soars
past $4. This is TCA's answer to relieving OC traffic?
So what's not to scream about?


TCA lawyer Thorton claims booing ensued at Feb. 6th's
Del Mar Coastal Commission's Public Hearing while
TCA's MacLean complains "meeting was chaotic."
Yet it was TCA who bused-in 100's of orange-shirted,
placard-waving "laborers" chanting "Toll Road!,"
clueless to why they were there except for TCA's
free lunch and 8-hour stipend.


MacLean complains the Hearing took place in Del Mar?
In North San Diego County? In a room large enough
to house 3,500 park-loving citizens comfortably (with
a 1000 more outside) for 18-long hours?


But San Onofre State Beach Park sits solely in North
San Diego County - Not OC. Does TCA's wrong-way
MacLean deny geographic reality too?


After 21 traffic boondoggling years, TCA still doesn't
know where it's going. It could make ya'scream.  

 
TCA: Trust Fund Babies' Tantrum
Monday, 07 April 2008
Marty Benson

The TCA's lack of regard for the truth, the public, and its use of other people's money is atrocious. I wish I could say it's surprising too, but lying and hemorrhaging money seem only natural for a company founded on the construction of roads for use by the wealthy few that's funded with developers' loans based on an understanding that the debtor has an indefinite, guaranteed revenue stream.

Now they want to subsidize the tolls with public funds to increase traffic. So let me get this straight: These guys came up with a business plan that didn't work, either because they set it up to fail or because of some very serious honest mistake(s). Now they want public funds to bail the venture out AND they want to continue building? I'm no investment banker (or Donald Trump, ha!), but it seems to me that a company with such a bleak and profound record of monetary and traffic relief failure (with a monopoly for Pete's Sake!) probably shouldn't be allowed to go further in debt. I, for one, would prefer my tax dollars be spent on something other than some failing company's debt interest and pouting attorney's fees.

http://blogs.ocweekly.com/navelgazing/241-toll-road/robert-thornton-professional-b/

 
Major Investment Study - outdated and incomprehensive
Written by Marty Benson   
Monday, 31 March 2008

The Orange County Transportation Authority has recently released and taken comment on their Major Investment Study which contains proposals for future transportation projects in Southern Orange County.  All of the proposals and projections in this study included the Transportation Corridor Agency’s 241 Foothill South Toll road proposal as a completed fixture in the Orange County transit system by their 2030 study horizon. 

Given that he TCA’s toll road proposal was axed by the California Coastal Commission (who have jurisdiction to approve or deny coastal development in California) on February 6, it would seem that a study presuming its construction is outdated and incomprehensive.  However, the study’s exclusion of projections without the toll road may be a little more insidious than they look at first blush.

Prior to February 6, OCTA’s MIS study was slated to factor the proposed toll road into some of its projections and alternatives.  The study was also to prepare analysis for future OC transportation without the toll road.  It was after the Coastal Commission nixed the toll road that the OCTA board of directors decided to scrap the analysis of the Orange County’s transportation future without the road. 

OCTA’s decision to eliminate analysis of Orange County without the toll road after the the toll road project’s rejection reeks of fowl play.  The study’s exclusion of the most likely scenario relative to the toll road must have been intended to be argumentative in favor of the toll road.  A decision I’d wager was primarily initiated by the several board members who sit on both the OCTA and TCA boards of directors. 

This hole in OCTA’s MIS study obstructs the view of Orange County’s transportation future and perpetrates an egregious waste of the taxpayers’ money that went to fund the study.

Marty Benson

 
Joel Reynolds's Blog California’s State Parks under Attack
Friday, 28 March 2008

California’s State Parks under Attack

March 27, 2008

Posted by Joel Reynolds in Saving Wildlife and Wild Places

Last week, conservationists in California lost two of their strongest allies for our state parks. Gov. Schwarzenegger removed Clint Eastwood and Bobby Shriver from their leadership posts on the California State Park and Recreation Commission after their vocal and effective opposition to a proposal to use the state park at San Onofre as right-of-way for a massive toll road – a proposal supported by the Governor.  It is pretty easy to read these dismissals as a warning shot by the Governor to all his appointees who have refused to support that terrible project. 

The proposed toll road would pave a six-lane highway through the park from top to bottom, requiring, according to California State Parks, that up to 60 percent of the park be closed.  This isn’t really a road through a state park; it’s a road instead of a state park.  And it wouldn’t even solve the traffic problem it is designed to address. The Governor claims “the road has to go somewhere” and this is “progress,” but the truth is, this isn’t progress, and it doesn’t have to go through a state park, and that’s precisely what Shriver and Eastwood said.   

The toll road project has been rejected overwhelmingly by the California Coastal Commission as illegal, but the road builders have appealed that rejection to the Bush Administration and asked that it be overturned.  We’re fighting that appeal and are committed, whichever way it comes out, to continue doing whatever is necessary to defeat this toll road and save San Onofre.  This is necessary not only to prevent the devastation of a state park visited by 2.5 million visitors each year, but because its destruction would create a terrible precedent state-wide, at a time when our parks system is under attack by budget cuts, park closures, and no less than 113 proposals for development across 73 of our state parks.  If this road can be built through San Onofre, similar projects are inevitable in state parks all across California. 

Under Schwarzenegger’s administration, California has become the proving ground for the clean energy economy. He’s been willing to go to bat against the EPA to win California’s right to enact the strictest emission standards across the country, setting the bar for 17 other states to follow. Many of his state initiatives serve as models for other states when it comes to renewable energy use and pollution reduction. As a native Californian, I’m proud of that progress, but that doesn’t give him a free pass to run highways through our cherished parks.  

Unfortunately, we can’t get Shriver or Eastwood their well deserved jobs back as chair and vice chair of the parks commission, respectively. Instead, we’re trying to make sure something like this doesn’t happen again. We’ve asked the state senate to hold oversight hearings concerning the range of threats to our state park system, including the dismissal of Shriver and Eastwood.

Schwarzenegger’s environmental record will speak for itself when his term has ended, but in the meantime, we need to ensure our state parks still have a voice to be heard.

Joel Reynold's Blog


 
Do you feel lucky, punk
Friday, 21 March 2008
This cartoon is being circulated, and I thought I'd share.

sfchroniclemarch212008.jpg

 
Heartfelt thanks
Wednesday, 20 February 2008

The Save San Onofre Coalition would like to thank each and every individual who took the time to write the Coastal Commission or attended the hearing. It's because of people like YOU that we continue our fight to Save the Park and Stop the Toll Road.

We have been receiving countless, heartfelt letters over the past few weeks. The letters really put this project into perspective and Californians dedication to preserve our environment.

I would like to present one letter in specific, from the La Joya community. Leslie A. Mayo is a 72 year-old resident who as a teen frequented the San Onofre State Beach. Her letter, as well as many others we received, show how much history this park has and reminds us why it's so special to so many of us.

Leslie A. Mayo Letter

 
Preserve California's legacy and heritage
Written by Dean LaTourrette   
Tuesday, 05 February 2008
As an avid outdoorsman and ocean-lover, as well as an open space and park advocate, I strongly urge Californians and the California Coastal Commission to reject the proposed 241 Toll Road project. Quite simply, this toll road/freeway project is a terrible idea. As you have likely already read, it will cut right down the middle of the park, destroying approximately 60% of usable open park space. It will dramatically increase polluted runoff into the San Mateo Creek Watershed, which empties out into the ocean at Trestles Beach, one of the best and most-visited surfing areas not just in California, but the world.

But I believe there is something even broader for everyone to think about: the environmental legacy of California, which carries tremendous environmental, economic, social and cultural impacts. This is a STATE PARK, the fifth most-visited park in the entire state. People come to California from all over the world to hike and camp in our parks, stroll on our beaches, surf and swim in our oceans, to enjoy our unparalleled natural assets. To build a freeway right down the middle of one of our premiere parks is just plain stupid, whether looking at it environmentally, socially or economically. It is the epitome of killing the goose that lays the golden egg, yet that is exactly what this proposal is contemplating.

Please, let’s be smart about this, take a long-term view, and protect the outstanding universal value of our natural assets in California.

Dean LaTourrette
Executive Director
Save The Waves Coalition
www.savethewaves.org

P.S. Good artist's rendition of San Onofre State Beach Park before and after the proposed project
 
The Effort To Save Trestles
Tuesday, 05 February 2008
It's obvious the mixed feelings about 241 toll road. No one enjoys sitting in traffic all day, but it's important to keep in mind what's really at hand here. The TCA is building this road through a California State Park. Over a hundred residents and members rallied against the proposed Toll Road Through San Onofre State Park just a few days ago. I have posted the pictures below. It's a strong indicator of the level of opposition surrounding this toll road.
 
Welcome to our new blog!
Written by Administrator   
Monday, 14 January 2008

Welcome to the newly redesigned webpage for Save San Onofre, and to our new blog!

We hope this new design will be more interactive for our supporters and will make it easier to get out the truth about San Onofre and the damage that will be done by the TCA’s proposed toll road.